The series is tied 1-1 as the teams head north for Game 3 in Brooklyn on Tuesday.
Jonathan Drouin and Victor Hedman also notched goals for the Lightning and Ben Bishop made 19 saves.
Hall of Famer Gordie Howe dies at age 88 - reports
Nicolay Kulemin had the Islanders' lone goal.
Toronto Maple Leafs win draft lottery, get first overall pick
Virtanen suspended for two games for interference - NHL Round Up